Key Takeaways
- U.S. Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the MIT-educated brothers of wire fraud in a $25 million Ethereum exploit.
- The judge said subverting MEV-Boost software on an unregulated marketplace without explicit rules is not criminal fraud.
- The acquittal closes the April 2023 case after a mistrial one year prior, clearing the Peraire-Bueno brothers.
How the MEV-Boost Exploit Worked
A Manhattan federal judge acquitted two Massachusetts Institute of Technology-educated brothers of fraud charges, ruling that prosecutors failed to prove their rapid $25 million Ethereum exploit involved material misrepresentations.
The decision comes approximately one year after a jury deadlocked following a nearly four-week trial, prompting U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke to declare a mistrial. Prosecutors had charged the brothers with wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering in connection with an April 2023 incident involving Ethereum’s transaction validation infrastructure.
Clarke determined that the government’s evidence was insufficient to support convictions, even when viewed in the light most favorable to prosecutors.
“The question before the court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” Clarke wrote. “It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case.”
The judge concluded that prosecutors had failed to prove an essential element of wire fraud: a materially false or misleading representation made in carrying out the alleged scheme.
The case centered on a trading strategy known as Omakase, which the brothers developed to exploit a vulnerability in MEV-Boost, open-source software introduced by Flashbots in 2022. MEV-Boost allows Ethereum validators to outsource the construction of transaction blocks to specialized operators. The system is designed to maximize the value extracted from transaction ordering while preventing validators from seeing certain transaction details before committing to a block.
According to prosecutors, the brothers identified a weakness in the software that enabled them to access private transaction information and manipulate the ordering of transactions.
On April 23, 2023, the brothers allegedly baited automated “sandwich-trading” bots, which profit by placing orders immediately before and after a user’s trade, before exploiting a software flaw to expose private data and swap in their own transactions.
The maneuver netted the brothers roughly $25 million while costing the bots millions, with the court noting the targeted traders were already attempting to profit at other Ethereum users’ expense. In one trial example, a Savannah Technologies bot swapped $2.3 million in USDC for $8.25 worth of Shiba Inu tokens, expecting to profitably reverse the trade before the brothers interrupted the sequence.
Subverting Code vs. Criminal Fraud
Prosecutors argued the brothers deceived participants by submitting misleading transactions, falsely committing to validate blocks and manipulating standard software procedures.
However, Clarke rejected those claims, ruling the conduct did not meet the legal standard for wire fraud because the bait transactions contained no false promises or enforceable commitments to process trades as others expected. Distinguishing between subverting a decentralized system’s intended design and committing criminal fraud, she noted that undermining participant expectations on an unregulated marketplace without rules barring the strategy does not constitute deception.
In its analysis, the court rejected the government’s contention that violating the spirit of MEV-Boost’s design was sufficient to establish wire fraud.
Daniel Marx, an attorney representing Anton Peraire-Bueno at Fick & Marx, said the decision confirmed that the brothers had not deceived other market participants.
“From the start, this flawed prosecution was based on fundamental misunderstandings about decentralized financial networks, like Ethereum,” Marx said in a statement.
He added that the ruling established that the brothers “never lied to anyone about their trading activity.”


